On May 21, the Chechen website kavkazcenter.com, which is controlled by Movladi Udugov, the eminence grise behind self-styled Amir of the North Caucasus Doku Umarov, posted a photo, which it claimed to have received earlier that day, of a man who closely resembles Yamadayev. The man is lying propped up on pillows in a hospital bed.
Sulim's brother Isa Yamadayev has acknowledged the likeness between Sulim and the man in the photograph, but said he has never seen the photo before and does not know where and when it was taken.
A second, unidentified relative suggested that the photo may have been a montage. That relative also argued forcefully that if the family had wanted to circulate photographic evidence that Sulim is indeed alive, as Isa Yamadayev has repeatedly claimed he is, they would not have sent it to Udugov's "separatist" website.