Accessibility links

Breaking News

Fake News, Soviet-Style: The Armenian Earthquake Rescue That Was Too Good To Be True

Buried in a cold basement under tons of crumbled Soviet concrete after a devastating earthquake, six Armenian men ate jarred pickles and canned fruit for 35 days before being miraculously rescued on a wintry day in January 1989.

Seemingly disoriented 50-year-old electrician Haikaz Hakopian was shown on a hospital bed in the Armenian capital, Yerevan, telling the men's amazing tale of underground survival -- the longest anyone had ever spent beneath earthquake rubble and lived to tell about it.

"I remember I was in the cellar with my neighbors and then dishes started breaking," Hakopian recounted. "I remember we tried to get up. I don't remember much after that."

He added that he had sung songs and told tales to help keep the other five men entertained during their ordeal, dubbed by Soviet news agency TASS the "Leninakan miracle," after the city where it all happened.

Hakopian and the others' saga reverberated throughout the Soviet Union and beyond, and was quickly picked up by foreign media outlets, including The New York Times.

It was an inspirational story of human hope and survival, but there was one problem: It was a hoax.

An early instance of fake news, Soviet-style.

The tragedy itself had been all too real. The temblor that struck northern Armenia on December 7, 1988, killed more than 25,000 people, injured up to 130,000, and left hundreds of thousands homeless or without basic supplies.

But exactly two weeks later, a Libyan bomb blew up Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie, Scotland, killing all 259 people aboard and 11 more on the ground. That brutal terrorist attack snatched the global spotlight from Armenia and vast swaths of the international community seemingly forgot about the plight of the earthquake's victims.

That's when Artyom Shahbazian, a reporter for Soviet Armenia's Armenpress news agency, decided to fabricate a remarkable story to refocus global attention on Soviet Armenia's horrific tragedy, three of his former colleagues tell RFE/RL.

Shahbazian -- who emigrated to Israel after the break-up of the Soviet Union and who died in Canada in 2005 -- was convinced that his countrymen needed his help, they said.

"Western countries had already begun to forget about it," Lyova Azroyan, a longtime Armenpress reporter based in Yerevan, tells RFE/RL. "That's why [he said he] invented the story."

Shahbazian sent his bogus story of the rescue to TASS so that it would get international distribution, according to Azroyan.

Another account suggests that a TASS reporter was with Shahbazian in Leninakan and conspired to make up the report.

But Aram Ananian, the current director of Armenpress, tells RFE/RL he knows that Shahbazian was the author.

PHOTO GALLERY: On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.

Still Recovering: Armenia's Catastrophic Earthquake, 30 Years Later

Gyumri (known during the Soviet period as Leninakan) photographed two years before disaster struck. The city is Armenia's second-largest, after the capital, Yerevan.
1/18 Gyumri (known during the Soviet period as Leninakan) photographed two years before disaster struck. The city is Armenia's second-largest, after the capital, Yerevan.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
A clock in Gyumri, frozen at the moment the earthquake struck, when workers and schoolchildren were inside on a chilly Wednesday.
2/18 A clock in Gyumri, frozen at the moment the earthquake struck, when workers and schoolchildren were inside on a chilly Wednesday.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
A man holds the body of his dead child in Gyumri. The quake lasted just 20 seconds, with a magnitude of 6.8, but the dust cleared to scenes of utter devastation. 
3/18 A man holds the body of his dead child in Gyumri. The quake lasted just 20 seconds, with a magnitude of 6.8, but the dust cleared to scenes of utter devastation. 
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Most residential buildings in the region were shoddy Soviet-era apartment blocks that crumpled into piles of rubble.
4/18 Most residential buildings in the region were shoddy Soviet-era apartment blocks that crumpled into piles of rubble.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Rescue workers scrambling through broken concrete in Gyumri. Of 78 high-rise apartment blocks in the city, just six survived the quake.
5/18 Rescue workers scrambling through broken concrete in Gyumri. Of 78 high-rise apartment blocks in the city, just six survived the quake.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Many of the region's buildings cracked at their base, leading to some structures toppling like felled trees.
6/18 Many of the region's buildings cracked at their base, leading to some structures toppling like felled trees.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev (left) cut short a visit to New York, where he had been feted by the press and thousands of cheering Americans, to fly into Soviet Armenia's nightmare.
7/18 Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev (left) cut short a visit to New York, where he had been feted by the press and thousands of cheering Americans, to fly into Soviet Armenia's nightmare.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Grieving locals near their destroyed house. Gorbachev declared, "In my entire life, I've never seen one-thousandth of the suffering I've seen here.”
8/18 Grieving locals near their destroyed house. Gorbachev declared, "In my entire life, I've never seen one-thousandth of the suffering I've seen here.”
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Workers transporting a coffin. Unlike previous carefully censored disasters in the Soviet Union, the earthquake's aftermath took place under the glare of a newly unleashed Soviet media, thanks to Gorbachev's policy of glasnost, or "openness."
9/18 Workers transporting a coffin. Unlike previous carefully censored disasters in the Soviet Union, the earthquake's aftermath took place under the glare of a newly unleashed Soviet media, thanks to Gorbachev's policy of glasnost, or "openness."
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
A man grieving over a loved one. The press coverage was devastating for the U.S.S.R. as revelations of reckless construction sent shockwaves through the Soviet public.
10/18 A man grieving over a loved one. The press coverage was devastating for the U.S.S.R. as revelations of reckless construction sent shockwaves through the Soviet public.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Soviet soldiers working to clear the piles of rubble. Gorbachev asked one interviewer, "Who is to blame for the fact that in the concrete blocks there is too little cement but more than enough sand? This means the cement was stolen. By whom?"
11/18 Soviet soldiers working to clear the piles of rubble. Gorbachev asked one interviewer, "Who is to blame for the fact that in the concrete blocks there is too little cement but more than enough sand? This means the cement was stolen. By whom?"
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Along with Gyumri, the town of Spitak (pictured) was leveled, with most of the town's population lying "entombed” after the quake.
12/18 Along with Gyumri, the town of Spitak (pictured) was leveled, with most of the town's population lying "entombed” after the quake.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
A survivor trapped under tons of rubble. International help soon poured into Armenia, leading to the largest international cooperation since WWII.
13/18 A survivor trapped under tons of rubble. International help soon poured into Armenia, leading to the largest international cooperation since WWII.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Barrels of fish being prepared for airlift into Armenia from Soviet Kyrgyzstan. As foreign aid descended on Armenia, Gyumri's airport, which usually received around four arrivals per day, was soon fielding as many as 180.
14/18 Barrels of fish being prepared for airlift into Armenia from Soviet Kyrgyzstan. As foreign aid descended on Armenia, Gyumri's airport, which usually received around four arrivals per day, was soon fielding as many as 180.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
On December 12, a Soviet military transport plane crashed on approach to the chaotic Gyumri airport, killing 78 people. Soon afterward, a Yugoslav plane -- also part of the relief effort -- crashed near Yerevan, killing seven.
15/18 On December 12, a Soviet military transport plane crashed on approach to the chaotic Gyumri airport, killing 78 people. Soon afterward, a Yugoslav plane -- also part of the relief effort -- crashed near Yerevan, killing seven.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
As winter closed in, some 150,000 survivors were left homeless in the mountainous north of Armenia. Soon afterward, as the Soviet Union collapsed, aid and rebuilding efforts stalled.
16/18 As winter closed in, some 150,000 survivors were left homeless in the mountainous north of Armenia. Soon afterward, as the Soviet Union collapsed, aid and rebuilding efforts stalled.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Today Gyumri is yet to recover, with rebuilding happening in fits and starts and hundreds of people still living in makeshift housing. This structure has been built around a mobile trailer.
17/18 Today Gyumri is yet to recover, with rebuilding happening in fits and starts and hundreds of people still living in makeshift housing. This structure has been built around a mobile trailer.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Earthquake-damaged buildings in Gyumri in 2013. Since the quake, which destroyed most of the town&#39;s factories, the population has nearly halved. For quake survivors and many other Armenians, the lure of a job in neighboring Russia is strong. One Gyumri local <a href="https://eurasianet.org/armenia-residents-still-living-the-spitak-earthquake" target="_blank">told a reporter</a> in 2013 that &quot;unemployment and poverty are more terrifying&quot; than the prospect of another earthquake.
18/18 Earthquake-damaged buildings in Gyumri in 2013. Since the quake, which destroyed most of the town's factories, the population has nearly halved. For quake survivors and many other Armenians, the lure of a job in neighboring Russia is strong. One Gyumri local told a reporter in 2013 that "unemployment and poverty are more terrifying" than the prospect of another earthquake.
On December 7, 1988, an earthquake shattered the north of Soviet Armenia. Three decades later, the region is yet to recover from a disaster that killed more than 25,000 people and destroyed tens of thousands of homes.
Previous slide
Next slide

An Even Bigger Hoax

Another Armenpress journalist at the time, Armen Dulian, concurs that the rescue hoax was Shahbazian's work. He also acknowledges to RFE/RL that he wrote even more of a whopper in the quake's aftermath.

But the fake story by Dulian, who subsequently worked for RFE/RL and remains a popular fixture on Armenian Public Television, appears to have been quickly spotted as a hoax. In it, he wrote that several pregnant women in the earthquake zone had given birth to babies with superhuman abilities like night vision and fur, presumably due to the cold conditions their mothers had been subjected to.

Dulian said he also wrote his "superbaby" tale in hopes of highlighting the poor conditions his compatriots were enduring since the initial tragedy. "I wanted to draw the attention of the world to our misfortune," Dulian told RFE/RL in the run-up to the 30th anniversary of the Armenian earthquake. "That's why I invented the story. I didn't expect that the world could perceive it as a true story. It was a mistake that I never repeated in my journalistic career."

Although Dulian's ridiculous, U.S. tabloid-like story about freakish babies was probably laughed at by most readers, he said some media outlets actually believed it and that a German TV crew called him to come to Armenia to film the unusual babies. He had to tell them the story was a hoax.

Real People

Shahbazian's equally fictional story of the pickle-eating Hakopian's rescue was seemingly more believable.

Despite countless stories after earthquakes around the world in which survivors exaggerate or mistakenly recount the amount of time they spent under rubble before their rescue, Shahbazian's story seemed plausible -- particularly after Hakopian appeared on Soviet TV talking about his ordeal.

Although Shahbazian seems to have taken the details of his ruse with him to the grave, Hakopian was a real person who seemingly survived the earthquake.

A TV report on the U.S.S.R.'s popular Vremya news program claimed Hakopian was brought to Yerevan from the stricken city of Leninakan (which is today known as Gyumri).

Dulian says Shahbazian had gone to Leninakan and may have met Hakopian there. Whether those two concocted the story together or Shahbazian simply embellished Hakopian's original account of a rescue is unclear.

Some reports -- excluding the fake one -- stated that Hakopian's wife and four children had been killed in the tragedy. A doctor was even on hand for the television report to say that Hakopian's condition was satisfactory.

The other five men were reportedly not brought to Yerevan for treatment -- only Hakopian.

New Transparency, Exposing Lies

It didn't take long for Soviet officials to begin to doubt the authenticity of the January 13, 1989, TASS report about the six miracle survivors.

The next day, The New York Times reported that Soviet media had "cast doubt" on the report of the miraculous January 11 rescue. TASS reported that it could "neither confirm or deny" the account, and Armenian officials told The New York Times that its branch of the Soviet Health Ministry was trying to "verify the facts and find all of" the six purported survivors.

The New York Times expressed hope that its story of the rescue "might yet turn out to be true" and offered a sliver of praise to the openness in the media brought on by Mikhail Gorbachev's rise to power in the Soviet Union.

It noted that Gorbachev had "brought not only a new liveliness but also a new element of uncertainty into [the Soviet media and] what used to be a monolithic propaganda machine, one that was counted on for consistency, if not always truth."

The central Soviet newspaper Izvestia announced it had been unable to find any of the other men cited by Hakopian as having been rescued and had launched an investigation into the "Leninakan miracle."

Hakopian was even said to have been given a psychiatric evaluation and found to be "completely normal." Though a TV report said he acted "exhausted and distracted" during an interview, casting doubt on the accuracy of some of the quotations attributed to him by TASS."

But a day later the charade was seemingly over.

The New York Times printed a story titled Soviets Say Armenian Invented Ordeal In Quake, with TASS reporting that Hakopian and his sister seemed to have made up the story about being trapped for 35 days under the rubble.

More recently, in the weeks ahead of the 30th anniversary of the Armenian tragedy, efforts by RFE/RL -- including pleas on a local Gyumri TV station and social media -- to locate Hakopian or any of the other men named in the bogus rescue report were unsuccessful.

Sergei Nazaretian, an adviser to the director of the Armenian National Service for Seismic Protection, tells RFE/RL that the last recorded rescue after the 1988 earthquake was the discovery of a victim 13 days later.

It will likely never be known if Hakopian and Shahbazian knew each other or collaborated in some way on the fake story.

It's also difficult to know whether Shahbazian's fake news story succeeded in getting the world to pay more attention to the horrible predicament the Armenian people were in.

What is certain is that even 30 years later, many of the cities in northern Armenia hit hardest by the earthquake are still struggling.

Written by Pete Baumgartner based on reporting by Harutyun Mansuryan
  • 16x9 Image

    Pete Baumgartner

    Pete Baumgartner is the editor for Central Asia and China for RFE/RL's Central Newsroom in Prague.

  • 16x9 Image

    Harutyun Mansuryan

    Harutyun Mansuryan is a multimedia video producer for RFE/RL in Prague.

This item is part of
XS
SM
MD
LG