WASHINGTON -- US and European officials have edged closer to unity on a Ukraine peace framework, with Washington open to NATO-style security guarantees and US envoy Jared Kushner saying Moscow may be receptive to the idea.
But Russia cast doubt on that assertion and talks involving Ukrainian and Western officials in Berlin left major questions unresolved, including how Ukraine would be protected against another Russian attack, whether its territorial integrity would be preserved, and what concessions might be required for a settlement.
As European leaders push for a role in peace negotiations alongside the US, Ukraine, and Russia, US envoy Steve Witkoff said “important work remains.”
Witkoff, who attended the Berlin meeting on November 19 along with Kushner, President Donald Trump's son-in-law, described the discussions as “frank and productive.” He said Trump was determined to end the war in a way that preserves Ukraine's security and sovereignty and prevents a recurrence of conflict.
The meeting of the Coalition of the Willing, a group of countries coordinating military and other support for Ukraine, was hosted by German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and attended by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and other leaders. It sought to strengthen Western support for Kyiv and secure a European role in US-led peace efforts.
NATO-Style Security Guarantees Gain Traction
Kushner offered an indication of the US administration's thinking on Ukraine's postwar security, saying Washington had made progress in securing Russian acceptance of the idea of an Article 5-style guarantee -- a commitment modeled on NATO's collective-defense clause, under which an attack on one member is considered an attack on all.
“From America's perspective, giving an Article 5-like security guarantee is a really, really big deal,” he said, adding that Trump was open to the idea, provided it served US interests and formed part of a broader security package.
Kushner said Washington had made Moscow “comfortable” with the concept, arguing that Russia also wanted to avoid another war after the current conflict. He acknowledged, however, that skepticism remained about Moscow's intentions.
Russia, which wants any peace deal to include a bar on Ukraine ever joining NATO, threw cold water on the idea that Moscow might accept an arrangement that included Article 5-like guarantees for Ukraine.
"I want to say that even finding a formula for 'quasi-membership' in NATO for Kyiv -- or seeking some sort of, in quotation marks, 'creative solution' in this area -- is an unacceptable option for us," Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said on November 20.
Kyiv and the West "should acknowledge the nonnegotiable nature of our demand that [Ukraine] must not join NATO," the Russian news agency Interfax quoted Ryabkov as saying. "Once that happens, I believe the question of security guarantees could, in one way or another, be discussed."
SEE ALSO:
Pentagon Official Says Ukraine War Likely To Last Through Winter, Despite Mediation EffortsAn Article 5-like guarantee could replicate elements of NATO's collective-defense commitment without making Ukraine a member of the alliance. Its credibility would depend on the legal obligations, military arrangements, and the willingness of participating countries to respond to another Russian attack.
Zelenskyy said Ukraine would like more clarity on what such a guarantee would involve. "I'm not sure that we have a common [understanding] of Article 5," he said, adding that for him, it means "that there some forces of partners on your land" and suggesting that in his view, US and European forces should be based in Ukraine.
Meanwhile, French President Emmanuel Macron urged Ukraine's allies to reconsider NATO membership rather than rely exclusively on alternative security arrangements.
“Faced with the maximalist nature of the Russian position, I believe we need to reopen the question of Ukraine's accession to NATO,” Macron said.
Macron also called for urgent deliveries of air-defense systems and interceptors to protect Ukrainian civilians and critical infrastructure from Russian missile and drone attacks.
Europe Presses For Binding Guarantees
A joint statement following the Berlin meeting by the leaders of Germany, France, Britain, and Ukraine reaffirmed that Kyiv must receive robust, legally binding security guarantees once a cease-fire takes effect.
The proposed framework could include sustained military, financial and technical assistance, participation in a US-led cease-fire monitoring mechanism and a European-led multinational force supported by Washington.
SEE ALSO:
Wider Europe Briefing: Europe's Fruitless Search For A Ukraine Peace Envoy; EU Safeguards For MontenegroThe force could provide reassurance measures on land, at sea and in the air while helping consolidate Ukraine's armed forces. The leaders also envisaged a legally binding commitment, subject to national procedures, to take measures to restore peace and security if Russia attacks again.
Moscow vocally opposes Western troop deployments in Ukraine as part of security guarantees, a position President Vladimir Putin repeated this week.
The joint statement stressed that Ukraine's sovereignty, territorial integrity and right to choose its security arrangements must be respected. It also rejected changing international borders by force.
The coalition pledged continued military and financial support for Kyiv and increased economic pressure on Moscow, including measures targeting Russian energy revenues, cryptocurrency transactions, illicit financial flows, and its military-industrial complex.
The European leaders also called for an energy cease-fire during the winter and an arrangement to protect food exports through the Black Sea, as Russian attacks threaten Ukraine's power supplies and the war continues to disrupt maritime trade.
SEE ALSO:
Putin Has Shown No Willingness To End Ukraine War, Says Mike PompeoMerz said further peace negotiations were expected soon, with Europe participating alongside the US, Russia, and Ukraine. He suggested the United Arab Emirates as a possible neutral venue.
Kushner said Trump wanted an agreement developed with European and Ukrainian participation, not imposed unilaterally by Washington. “President Trump wants to make a deal with Europe by his side,” he said.
Trump's Russia Policy Faces Scrutiny
The diplomatic efforts are unfolding amid growing criticism in Washington of Trump's recent engagement with Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese leader Xi Jinping.
Trump met Putin and Xi at an unprecedented trilateral summit in Shenzhen, China, on November 19, which produced no breakthrough on ending Russia's war in Ukraine. A joint US-Chinese-Russian statement made no mention of the war.
The senior Democrat in the US Senate, Chuck Schumer, dismissed the trilateral meeting as a diplomatic embarrassment, arguing that Trump had secured no meaningful commitments on Ukraine or international security. Jeanne Shaheen, the top Senate Democrat on foreign policy, said defeating Putin in Ukraine remained essential to US national security.
SEE ALSO:
Trump, Xi, And Putin Make History, But No Breakthroughs: 4 Takeaways From The Trilateral SummitRepresentative Gregory Meeks, the senior Democrat on the Foreign Affairs Committee in the House of Representatives, said the summit had not advanced nuclear nonproliferation, ended Russia's war, or addressed Chinese human rights abuses.
Republican Senator Thom Tillis also questioned the intentions of Moscow and Beijing, while Representative Don Bacon criticized Trump's approach, saying Republicans had traditionally stood up to Russia and China.
Democratic Senator Tim Kaine introduced a resolution seeking answers from the administration about purchases of Russian fuel, sanctions relief, and delays in delivering air-defense munitions to Ukraine. He argued that buying Russian fuel risked providing Moscow with revenue to finance its war.