Accessibility links

Breaking News

Russian Media Coverage Of The Donetsk Attack On Pro-Ukraine Protesters


Clashes in Donetsk.
This is what we know happened in Donetsk on April 28: About 2,000 demonstrators gathered in the center of the eastern city for a march in support of a united Ukraine.

They were attacked by some 100 men wielding various accoutrements -- including metal rods, baseball bats, and truncheons.

How do we know this is what happened? Our reporters were there:
Pro-Russia Militants Attack Ukrainian Unity March In Donetsk
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:01:55 0:00

But you don't have to take our word for it.

From the Global Post:

From "The Telegraph":

A short video report from ITV News:

Server error

Oops, as you can see, this is not what we wanted to show you!

This URL has been sent to our support web team to look into it immediately. Our apologies.

Please use Search above to see if you can find it elsewhere


It's usually not this simple. On April 27, when pro-Kyiv football ultras clashed with pro-Russian separatists there was clearly violence emanating from both sides. In the case of yesterday's events in Donetsk, however, the evidence of a largely one-sided attack appears to be overwhelming.

But Russian media has an altogether different story.

From ITAR-TASS, a state-run news agency:
"On April 28, masked men shouting nationalist slogans attacked a [pro-Russian] anti-fascist rally. Several dozen radical [pro-Kyiv] activists began throwing stones at the [pro-Russian] procession. They also reportedly had grenades. Rebuffed, the attackers fled."

In linking to the report, Tikhon Dzyadko, a host for the liberal Russian Dozhd TV channel, said ITAR-TASS had gone from "continuing to lie" to "plain fantasizing."

Russian TV blamed pro-Kyiv football hooligans for attacking "pro-federalization" protesters.

The Pravda.ru website took the story a step further, claiming the pro-Kyiv protesters -- linked in the report to a Nazi SS "glorification" group -- tried to carry out a "real cleaning" of the streats of Donetsk.
"The [pro-Kyiv] radicals started to attack people, including passersby, beating them with bats," a report on the site said.

Meanwhile, Graham Phillips, a freelancer for RT, the Russian government's English-language outlet, said Western journalists were being overly simplistic in their descriptions of events.

Although he granted that the pro-Russia side was "just militant today," he said the pro-Kyiv demonstrators had a "peaceful and militant side." And he appeared to blame the "militants" on the Ukrainian side for purposely marching the demonstrators into a pro-Russian attack.

An RT report relied almost exclusively on Phillips' curated tweets -- excluding the one about the militant nature of the Russian side and another about hundreds of peaceful Ukrainians -- and on quotes from the press spokesperson of the self-proclaimed People's Republic of Donetsk, who told RT 1,000 "neo-Nazi thugs" had attacked peaceful pro-Russian protesters.

-- Glenn Kates, with reporting by RFE/RL's Ukrainian Service

Your opinion

Show comments

XS
SM
MD
LG