Zelenskiy Defends Decision To Swap Berkut Fighters With Separatists Amid Tearful Reunions In Kyiv
By RFE/RL's Ukrainian Service
Western leaders and Russia have welcomed a mass prisoner exchange amid efforts to end the five-year war between Kyiv and Russia-backed separatists fighting in Ukraine's east.
The swap of 200 prisoners, which took place at a checkpoint near the separatist-held city of Horlivka in the eastern Donetsk region on December 29, included military personnel, civilians, members of Ukraine's disbanded Berkut security forces, and two RFE/RL journalists.
Ukraine handed over 124 prisoners, while the separatists turned over 76 prisoners as part of a deal negotiated during a meeting of the so-called Normandy Four -- Ukraine, Russia, Germany, and France -- in Paris on December 9.
In a December 30 statement, Russia's Foreign Ministry described the handover as a "crucial humanitarian step that allowed dozens of people to reunite with their families and celebrate the New Year with their families and loved ones."
French President Emmanuel Macron and German Chancellor Angela Merkel welcomed the prisoner exchange in a joint statement released on December 29.
"The prisoner swap that was completed today is a long-awaited humanitarian measure,” read the statement released by the French president's office. “In line with the decisions taken at the Paris summit, it must now be followed by the full implementation of the cease-fire."
A spokesman for the European Union's foreign policy chief, Josep Borrell, called it "a welcome example of implementation" of one of the measures agreed at the Normandy summit.
"The European Union expects all parties to further build on this momentum," the spokesman added. "Work to implement the measures agreed at the summit must continue."
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy joined family members and supporters of the former prisoners who gathered at Kyiv's Boryspil Airport late in the evening of December 29 to greet the returnees.
"The people are home. We did what we said: [The prisoner swap took place] before the New Year," Zelenskiy told reporters after the tearful welcoming. "So, they will celebrate New Year with their families, in their homes, with parents, with children. That is great. I am happy and -- I am convinced -- so are they."
Zelenskiy also addressed the controversial decision to hand over five Berkut members accused of killing participants of the 2014 Euromaiden protests that led to the ouster of Moscow-friendly President Viktor Yanukovych.
"If we hadn’t exchanged Berkut fighters, we would not have returned our people -- living people," Zelenskiy told reporters after greeting the former captives upon their arrival at Kyiv's Boryspil Airport. "If I could give away 100 Berkut fighters in order to return one of our scouts, I would do it."
Tearful Reunions As Former Ukrainian Captives Return Home
Families of protesters killed by riot police during the pro-Western unrest in 2014 had publicly objected to any of the police officers convicted in those killings being part of a trade, warning in an open letter on Facebook that the release of the men could lead to a "wave of protests."
Among those Ukraine received were 12 military personnel and 64 civilians, including RFE/RL contributors Stanislav Aseyev and Oleh Halaziuk, who had been held by the separatists since 2017.
“We are thrilled and relieved that Stas and Oleh have been released,” RFE/RL President Jamie Fly said in a December 29 press release. “They were held incommunicado for 2 1/2 years, not because of any crime they committed, but because they reported the truth about Russia’s occupation of their homeland."
PEN America, an open expression advocacy group, also welcomed the journalists' release.
“Reporters and writers have been frequent targets of Russia-backed separatists during the brutal conflict in eastern Ukraine," said Polina Kovaleva, PEN America's Eurasia project director. "Those separatists’ kangaroo courts and sham proceedings kept these two men from their families and work for far too long.”
The swap was the second major prisoner exchange involving Ukrainians caught up in the conflict in four months and the fourth large-scale swap since the Donbas conflict started.
Russia and Ukraine traded a total of 70 prisoners on September 7 in a move that many regarded as progress in efforts to deescalate the war that has killed more than 13,000 people since Moscow forcibly annexed Crimea and Russia-backed gunmen grabbed swaths of eastern Ukraine in 2014.
Russia insists it is not a party to the conflict, despite significant evidence that includes communication with separatist leaders, captured Russians, and Russian casualties in the fighting.
Nearly 400 prisoners were exchanged in December 2017 and more than 200 in February 2015.
With reporting by Reuters, AFP, AP, dpa, UNIAN, Interfax, and RFE/RL correspondent Rikard Jozwiak in Brussels
That concludes our live-blogging of the situation in Ukraine for Sunday, December 29, 2019. Check back here tomorrow for more of our continuing coverage.
More on today's prisoner swap from RFE/RL's News Desk:
It included the handover to the government side of two RFE/RL contributors who had been held by separatists since 2017: Stanislav Aseyev and Oleh Halaziuk.
A number of rights and press groups had urged the release of Aseyev and Halaziuk over the past two years.
Aseyev was sentenced by separatists in October to 15 years in captivity for alleged espionage in a process that rights and press-freedom groups called "illegal" and "shocking."
Halaziuk was a professor at a Kharkiv economic institute before he started blogging under the pseudonym Myroslav Tyamushchiy to chronicle life in a war zone after the outbreak of the conflict in eastern Ukraine in 2014.
"We are thrilled and relieved that Stas and Oleh have been released,” said RFE/RL President Jamie Fly, who had urged Zelenskiy to seek the men's release during a meeting in Kyiv last month.
“They were held incommunicado for 2 1/2 years, not because of any crime they committed, but because they reported the truth about Russia’s occupation of their homeland."
Fly went on to thank the Ukrainian government and the so-called Trilateral Contact Group for their work toward winning the journalists' freedom.
Ukraine, Russia-Backed Separatists Complete Prisoner Swap
The latest from RFE/RL's Ukrainian Service:
Ukrainian authorities and Russia-backed separatists in eastern Ukraine have completed what was billed as an "all-for-all" prisoner swap near the village of Horlivka on December 29, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy's office said.
But it wasn't immediately clear how many prisoners -- which included fighters from the separatist ranks and civilians and servicemen long held in the breakaway regions -- were transferred in all.
"Mutual release of detained persons has ended, " the presidential office said in a tweet, adding, "76 of ours are safe in Ukraine-controlled territory. Details later."
Serhiy Sivoha, an adviser to the Ukrainian Security and Defense Council with ties to Zelenskiy's office, told Ukraine's Hromadske TV that Ukraine had gotten 76 of its nationals back and handed over 127 detainees within the framework of the exchange.
Earlier, the UNIAN news agency had quoted a representative of the Donetsk separatists as saying that the Ukrainian side was expected to hand over 87 people, while the separatists were set to swap 55.
The swap was the second major prisoner exchange involving Ukrainians caught up in the conflict in four months.
An RFE/RL contributor, Stanislav Aseyev, who had been held by separatists since 2017, was among the prisoners handed over to the Ukrainian government.
Aseyev had been sentenced by separatists to 15 years in captivity for alleged espionage in a process that rights and press-freedom groups called "illegal" and "shocking."
There was no immediate word on whether another RFE/RL contributor, blogger Oleh Halaziuk, who has been held by separatists in the Donetsk region since 2017, was also among those freed.
The notion of an "all-for-all" prisoner exchange gained momentum during peace talks in Paris on December 9 among the so-called Normandy Four -- Ukraine, Russia, France, and Germany -- trying to bring an end to the five-year conflict.
In the last swap, Russia and Ukraine traded a total of 70 prisoners in a move that many regarded as progress in efforts to deescalate a war that has killed more than 13,000 people since Moscow forcibly annexed Crimea and Russia-backed gunmen grabbed swaths of eastern Ukraine including parts of the Donetsk and Luhansk regions in 2014.
Russia insists it is not a party to the conflict, despite significant evidence that includes communication with separatist leaders, captured Russians, and Russian casualties in the fighting.
After the swap on December 29, the U.S. Embassy in Kyiv tweeted out congratulations of "liberated captives from Russia-controlled Donbas" and specifically cited "Russia's ongoing aggression [that] confronts Ukraine's leadership with difficult choices."
In Moscow, the Kremlin said Russian President Vladimir Putin and German Chancellor Angela Merkel had welcomed the prisoner swap as a "positive" development, AFP reported.
There was controversy ahead of the planned swap when families of protesters killed by riot police during pro-Western unrest in 2014 publicly objected to any of the police officers convicted in those killings being part of a trade.
Families of the victims of the riot policemen warned in an open letter on Facebook to Zelenskiy that the release of the men could lead to a "wave of protests."
"We would like to inform you that these people are neither participants nor victims of the conflict in eastern Ukraine," they wrote.
The conflict in the region known as the Donbas is one of the biggest challenges facing Zelenskiy, who campaigned on a vow to end the conflict. He was inaugurated on May 20.
The United States and European Union have imposed sanctions on Russia for its support of the separatists in eastern Ukraine and for the seizure and annexation of Ukraine’s Crimea region.