Accessibility links

Breaking News

Watchdog

Inmates say victims who try to complain about torture in Kazakh prison face even harsher treatment at the hands of authorities. (illustrations by Shapalaque)

Inmates at prisons in Kazakhstan are sharing harrowing details of what they describe as “torture” at the hands of their jailers.

“An officer pulled me out of the cell and began strangling me as others looked on. Then he hit me repeatedly on the head and in my face,” said one inmate of a prison in Almaty, whose name is being withheld out of concern for his safety.

“Next, five officers handcuffed me and dragged me into a specially adapted torture chamber to drown me in a water container,” he said. “I was tortured there until I passed out.’’

Many other detainees and prisoners in Kazakhstan say torture and other mistreatment is commonplace in Kazakhstan’s penitentiaries.

They claim that jailers act with impunity inside Kazakh prisons and that inmates who complain face more torture and mistreatment.

RFE/RL's Kazakh Service has obtained copies of letters from prisoners and detainees who have complained to Kazakh human rights defender Yelena Semyonova and two Kazakh rights groups -- the Kazakhstan International Bureau for Human Rights and Rule of Law and the Coalition Against Torture in Kazakhstan.

The rights activists say they receive hundreds of similar letters every year.

The letters suggest that systemic torture is often used to obtain confessions or to threaten detainees against filing formal complaints about mistreatment.

One inmate said he was brutally beaten by prison guards because he refused to hand over his prison salary to “cover someone else’s debts.”
Another letter claims prisoners were mistreated when “they refused to get a vaccination.” The letter doesn’t specify if the author was referring to COVID-19 vaccinations.

Another man described the ill-treatment he says he suffered at a police station in Atyrau Province.

“They shouted at me, kicked me, and beat me to force me to confess that I had stolen 12 bicycles,” the man wrote. “I told them I won’t take responsibility for a crime I didn’t commit.

“They beat me again in all places, then they handcuffed me and began strangling me with cellophane tape,” he wrote.

The man said he suffered such intense pain that he “swallowed a spoon" to "protect” himself and make them stop beating him. He was taken to a hospital, where he told the doctors about the beatings.

Later, during his trial, the man told the judge that he had been tortured into making a false confession. The judge disregarded his statement and found him guilty of stealing bicycles.

Semyonova, a longtime campaigner for the elimination of torture in Kazakh prisons, says it’s “almost impossible” for victims to prove they’ve been mistreated.

Semyonova says Kazakh authorities routinely fail to conduct adequate and impartial investigations into allegations of torture.

“Those who carry out probes usually speak to the same employees who are being accused of the mistreatment,” Semyonova told RFE/RL. “They also speak to a group of prisoners who are on good terms with prison officials. Ultimately, court rulings are based on these testimonies.”

Authorities say “99 percent of complaints by convicts and their relatives” about mistreatment at the hands of prison workers last year were not proven.

Complaints, Protests Ignored

One prisoner from the northern province of Qostanai wrote that he was repeatedly beaten by prison guards for no apparent reason. The man said his protests, complaints, and even a hunger strike that he staged were ignored by prison officials.

After [being tortured], I wrote on my body that the prison employees are responsible for my death,” one inmate said.

“When I was taken out for a walk, a guard started banging my head against the wall for no reason and then threw me into the cell,” he wrote. “I fell and hit my head. I asked to call the prosecutor, but they didn’t call anyone.”

The man said that when he cut his own hand in protest, “no medical treatment was provided” for him.

“Then I sewed my mouth shut and refused to eat for five days. But no one came to me,” he said. “I wrote complaints, but [prisons workers] wouldn’t send the letters anywhere.”

Like many others in similar cases, the man said that he would write messages on his body that he was being tortured in the hope that if he died from mistreatment, someone would find out about it.

“After [being tortured], I wrote on my body that the prison employees are responsible for my death,” the inmate said in his letter.

Another prisoner in Qaraghandy Province wrote that he would inflict harm on himself as a way to cry out for help amid unbearable torture.

“They would tie my hands behind my back and drag me out when the temperature was minus 20 degrees Celsius. They would hang me by the arms, douse my body with cold water, or cover me with snow, drown me, beat me unconscious.”

Many detainees and prisoners say that their defense attorneys advised them not to complain about being mistreated because it would inevitably lead to even more brutal torture.

One prisoner from the Aqmola region in central Kazakhstan said that law enforcement employees acted as if they thought their actions would never be punished.

“They behave like they’re above the law -- that I can’t prove their guilt because they have money and connections, while I’m just a convict who can be tortured. Where can I find justice?” the man wrote.

Out of 120 allegations of torture in prison facilities registered in Kazakhstan during the first five months of 2021, none of the cases has been sent to court.

Written by Farangis Najibullah in Prague with reporting by RFE/RL Kazakh Service correspondents Ayan Kalmurat and Aya Renaud
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban has been accused by the EU of flouting democracy with a series of laws seen as curtailing human rights and a free press.

Hungarian prosecutors have launched a probe into the alleged unlawful surveillance of critics of Prime Minister Viktor Orban as governments around the world continue to scramble to deal with the fallout from a scandal over the misuse of Israeli-made spyware.

A global-media consortium recently reported that spyware made by the Israel-based NSO Group may have been used to hack the smartphones of more than a dozen current or former world leaders, as well as hundreds of other officials, journalists, and rights activists worldwide.

The Budapest Regional Investigation Prosecutor's Office said on July 22 that it was launching an investigation after several complaints over allegations that local journalists and businessmen were spied on.

French President Emmanuel Macron called an urgent national-security meeting to weigh possible action after reports that his cellphone and those of government ministers may have been targeted by the Israeli-made Pegasus spyware.

In Jerusalem, Israeli lawmakers appointed an interministerial team to assess the reports -- based on an investigation by 17 media organizations -- that said Pegasus had been used in attempted or successful hacks of smartphones using malware that enables the extraction of messages, records calls, and secretly activates microphones.

One of Macron's mobile-phone numbers was reportedly found on a list of potential spying targets drawn up by Moroccan intelligence services. Morocco has denied any involvement that it has spied on any public figures; the French president's office was quick to point out that inclusion on the list did not mean that Macron's phone had actually been compromised.

However, if the reported facts are true, they are "of course very serious," it said in a statement.

Hungarian opposition lawmakers and rights activists immediately called for an inquiry after the spyware allegations were published on July 18 and included accusations that Orban's right-wing government may have used the powerful malware to spy on critical journalists, politicians, and business figures.

Direkt36, a Hungarian investigative-journalism outlet, has revealed that the phones of more than 300 Hungarian nationals were identified as possible targets for infection.

Amnesty International said its experts had confirmed several cases where the spyware was successfully installed on the phones of targets, noting that "Hungary’s surveillance practices have long been a matter of concern.”

"The task of the investigation is to establish the facts and to determine whether and, if so, what crime has taken place," the Budapest Regional Investigation Prosecutor's Office said in a statement.

Orban has been accused by the EU of flouting democracy with a series of laws seen as curtailing human rights and a free press. His government, however, has denied any use of the Pegasus software "in any way."

According to reports by the media consortium that investigated the issue, NSO Group's clients included both autocratic regimes and democratic governments: Azerbaijan, Bahrain, Hungary, India, Indonesia, Kazakhstan, Mexico, Morocco, Rwanda, Saudi Arabia, Togo, and the United Arab Emirates.

The NSO Group has rejected the reporting by the media partners, saying it was "full of wrong assumptions and uncorroborated theories." An NSO official said that Macron was not a target and that the company would review some cases that were revealed by the consortium and press clients about how they are using the system.

Amid mounting EU concern, German Chancellor Angela Merkel on July 22 called for "very restrictive conditions" on the trade in spyware such as Pegasus in countries in which judicial oversight is weak.

Merkel said it was "important" that "software configured in this way should not land in the wrong hands."

With reporting by Reuters, AP, and AFP

Load more

About This Blog

"Watchdog" is a blog with a singular mission -- to monitor the latest developments concerning human rights, civil society, and press freedom. We'll pay particular attention to reports concerning countries in RFE/RL's broadcast region.

Subscribe

Journalists In Trouble

RFE/RL journalists take risks, face threats, and make sacrifices every day in an effort to gather the news. Our "Journalists In Trouble" page recognizes their courage and conviction, and documents the high price that many have paid simply for doing their jobs. More

XS
SM
MD
LG