Accessibility links

Breaking News

Watchdog

Pouya Bakhtiari was shot and killed during a large protest in the Iranian city of Mehrshahr on November 16. (file photo)

A young man who described himself on Instagram as a "vegetarian electronic engineer" has become a face for the Islamic republic's deadliest political upheaval, which reportedly killed more than 200 people and left some 7,000 detained.

Pouya Bakhtiari was shot and killed during a large protest on November 16 that was triggered by a sudden hike in the price of gasoline.

Bakhtiari -- who loved Iranian history and calligraphy and enjoyed listening to Armenian-French singer Charles Aznavour -- had joined the protest in Mehrshahr, a district in the city of Karaj, with his mother and sister.

The 27-year old said he was fed up with the clerical establishment in the country, which he blamed for bringing Iranians misery during its more than four decades of rule.


The protest in Mehrshahr came following an overnight announcement by the government on November 15 of a steep hike in the price of gasoline that outraged many Iranians already struggling to make ends meet amid a worsening economy and tough U.S. sanctions. Some of the increases were more than 200 percent of the previous prices.

Washington's harsh trade restrictions and other measures against Iran have contributed to a drastic crash of the national currency and inflation in the prices of many basic goods.

Thousands of people poured into the streets of Karaj -- a city of some 1.5 million just west of the capital, Tehran -- to show their anger with the gas price hike. Many in the crowd feared the increase would result in even higher prices for other products and make the poor even poorer, as many chanted.

The protests -- which the Interior Ministry estimated were attended by at least 200,000 people, considered a conservative number -- quickly spread to more than 100 cities and towns around the country with some outraged protesters even shouting anti-establishment slogans that included wishing death to Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.

Iran Rocked By Deadly Fuel Protests
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:01:56 0:00

At the Mehrshahr protest, Bakhtiari and his mother lost each other in the crowd.

Minutes later, his mother saw protesters carrying a dead body and screaming: "We will kill those who killed our brother!"

She quickly realized it was her son who had been shot in the head and killed.

Bakhtiari was only one among dozens killed in what has been described as a particularly brutal state crackdown on several days of mass protests in Iran that included openly firing into crowds of unarmed demonstrators.

Compared by detained opposition figure Mir Hossein Musavi to the Shah of Iran's forces killing demonstrators in an event that ultimately led to the 1979 Islamic Revolution, the protests included a week-long, almost total shutdown of the Internet aimed at preventing the spread of the protests and making it difficult for the outside world to obtain credible information about the events.

But protesters managed to send dozens of videos outside of the country in which security forces, including plainclothes agents, are seen directly shooting at protesters.

Footage Shows Crackdown On Iranian Protests
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:01:24 0:00

Amnesty International has said that at least 208 protesters were killed in the protests while stating that the actual number of fatalities is likely to be much higher.

The opposition website Kaleme said on its Telegram channel that at least 366 people were killed. Iranian authorities have called the numbers exaggerated but they have so far failed to release an official tally.

'Criminal And Corrupt Regime'

Most of the families of the victims have remained silent due to pressure from authorities who have reportedly told them not to speak to the media and put restrictions on burials for their loved ones, according to rights groups.

But Bakhtiari's parents have been outspoken, giving interviews to media based outside the country, including RFE/RL and the BBC, and calling for accountability and justice.

"I served for five years on the front lines [during the 1980-1988 war with Iraq], but this is how [the authorities] answered me," his father, Manuchehr Bakhtiari, told RFE/RL in a telephone interview on December 4.

"They killed my son, but [officials] haven't even called us to offer their condolences," he added.

Bakhtiari's family also posted a video on Instagram that their son recorded on his mobile phone hours before being killed in which he expressed hope for an end to the "criminal and corrupt [Iranian] regime" while expressing hope for a new beginning for the Iranian people.

"I'm someone's son and I've come here and put my life in danger," he said in another video aired by the BBC.

Those words have been inscribed in graffiti messages honoring Bakhtari that have been spotted on the streets of Tehran.

'Maximum Pressure'

Unlike Bakhtiari, who according to his father worked and had a comfortable life, many of those taking part in and killed in the protests are reported to have come from low-income neighborhoods and provinces, including Shahriar in Tehran and the southwestern province of Khuzestan.

In Shahriar, 40 people were reportedly killed, while in Khuzestan -- home to the majority of Iran's ethnic Arabs -- the number of dead according to RFE/RL's Radio Farda is at least 58, including more than 20 killed in Mehrshahr where security forces reportedly used machine guns against protesters hiding in marshes. Reports said some of those killed had been armed and had shot at state security forces.

Iranian officials have claimed that the country's foreign "enemies," including the United States and Saudi Arabia, fomented the unrest, during which some 700 banks, 70 gas stations, dozens of other buildings, as well as police cars and ambulances were torched and damaged across the country, according to state officials.

The unrest comes amid the United States policy of "maximum pressure" on Iran, including an oil embargo that has devastated the economy.

Ali Vaez, the Iran project director at the International Crisis Group (ICG), told RFE/RL that Iran's leadership resorted rapidly "to an ironfisted approach because it saw the protests in Iran, Iraq, and Lebanon as part and parcel of the [United States'] 'maximum pressure' campaign."

"It could ill afford to allow the demonstrations to snowball into a nationwide movement," Vaez said, adding that "they now seem to believe that they have proven to the U.S. that they are in total control of their domestic sphere and are willing to pay any price to preserve their grip on power."

Ethnic 'Fault Lines'

For now, the Iranian establishment has managed to brutally crush the protests. But analysts warn that sooner or later there could be more unrest and even more violent protests.

"If Iranian leaders fail to recognize that the status quo has become untenable and major reforms are unavoidable, they are only buying time until the next uprising, which could lead to greater instability," Vaez said.

Vaez also warned that Tehran should also tread carefully in provinces where the country's ethnic minorities reside because "Iran has some of the same fault lines that pushed other countries in the region into catastrophic civil wars."

Saeid Golkar, an assistant political science professor at the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga and senior fellow on Iran policy at the Chicago Council on Global Affairs, says the Islamic republic is likelier to become more repressive than it is to reform.

"Learning from the Islamic republic's history and the personality of Ayatollah Khamenei, my guess is the Islamic government will invest more in security and military apparatuses than to reform itself."

Golkar says the Islamic republic, which came to power promising to help the oppressed and the poor, has lost "all its social bases."

"Disappointed and angry people -- mostly poor, young, and without a future -- poured into the streets to protest. Compared to the previous round of protests, for example, the 2009 Green Movement, the social composition of protesters is changing from the middle class to poor middle class and poor lower class."

Yegor Zhukov at a court hearing in Moscow on December 3

In the swirl of protests and arrests that gripped Moscow for weeks this past summer as Russians vented frustration with a repressive political system, an eloquent 21-year-old political-science student stood out from the crowds.

Prior to his predawn arrest on August 2, Yegor Zhukov, who studies at Moscow's prestigious Higher School of Economics, had already drawn a sizable audience on YouTube, where he had posted a series of video blogs in which he vented against President Vladimir Putin and promoted the opposition protests across the country.

The last video he posted before being detained had been viewed more than 300,000 times as of December 5. The videos posted to his YouTube channel, by his supporters and allies, since his arrest have garnered hundreds of thousands more.


Zhukov now faces as many as four years in prison -- the sentence prosecutors have requested for the charges of inciting extremism online. He is scheduled to be sentenced in the case on December 6 at the Kuntsevo district court in western Moscow.

In his final court appearance on December 4 before his sentencing the next day, Zhukov made an impassioned appeal to his supporters -- and offered an indictment of Russia's political system.

In doing so, he may end up joining a prominent list of individuals whose eloquent courtroom statements have entered the Russian popular imagination over the decades: Nobel laureate poet Joseph Brodsky, Ukrainian filmmaker Oleh Sentsov, and -- even more recently -- former Russian Economics Minister Aleksei Ulyukayev.

Russia's current political system has fostered economic inequality that, Zhukov said, destroys any opportunity for human prosperity, with the top 10 percent holding 90 percent of the nation’s wealth.

"Among them, of course, there are very honorable citizens, but the bulk of this wealth was obtained not by honest labor, for the benefit of people, but by banal corruption," he said.

"Our society is divided into two levels by an impenetrable barrier. All money is concentrated at the top, and nobody from there will give it back. From the bottom, without exaggeration, only hopelessness remains," he said.

WATCH: No One Safe As Moscow Police Lash Out (published August 5, 2019)

No One Safe As Moscow Police Lash Out
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:02:58 0:00


In the protests that clogged Moscow’s streets on consecutive weekends, police arrested dozens of people on various charges; most were released for minor misdemeanor violations.

But more than two dozen people have been prosecuted on more serious charges, with several receiving what their supporters have said were disproportionately harsh sentences.

Zhukov was initially charged with mass unrest as a result of his participation in the protests, but, amid an outcry from his student supporters, prosecutors reclassified the case against him.

The state has made it clear: 'Guys, you can wander around in your mink coats, just don’t interact with each other. More than two of you aren’t allowed to gather on the street. We’ll put you in jail for holding a demonstration."
-- Yegor Zhukov


In his final courtroom statement, Zhukov slammed what he said was the arbitrariness of the political system, asserting that authorities have allowed Russians to accumulate wealth as long as they don’t participate in any political demonstrations.

And he made passing criticism of the country's "foreign agent" law, which was recently tightened to allow the state to classify individual journalists and bloggers as foreign agents. Critics have warned that the law will further curb free speech and a free press.

"The state has made it clear: 'Guys, you can wander around in your mink coats, just don't interact with each other,'" he said. "More than two of you aren't allowed to gather on the street. We'll put you in jail for holding a demonstration. You're not allowed to work together on some socially beneficial project. We'll label you a 'foreign agent.' Where does trust come from in such an environment?"

He asserted that the government had “dehumanized” Russians, resulting in "an attitude that is highlighted every day by beatings with truncheons, torture in prisons, ignoring the HIV epidemic, closing schools and hospitals."

The result, he said, is a declining population, and "helplessness."

"Russia is gradually disappearing," he said, "at an average rate of 400,000 people a year. You don't see the people behind the statistics. So go find out who they really are! It's those [who] drink out of helplessness, it's those freezing in cold hospitals, it's those killed by someone else, it's those who are killing themselves."

Still, Zhukov said he was optimistic for the future.

"I look forward, beyond the horizon, years ahead, and see Russia filled with responsible and loving people, where there will be a truly happy place," he said. "Let everyone imagine such a Russia. Let this image guide you in your work in the same way that it guides me."

Load more

About This Blog

"Watchdog" is a blog with a singular mission -- to monitor the latest developments concerning human rights, civil society, and press freedom. We'll pay particular attention to reports concerning countries in RFE/RL's broadcast region.

Subscribe

Journalists In Trouble

RFE/RL journalists take risks, face threats, and make sacrifices every day in an effort to gather the news. Our "Journalists In Trouble" page recognizes their courage and conviction, and documents the high price that many have paid simply for doing their jobs. More

XS
SM
MD
LG