Accessibility links

Breaking News

Watchdog

Yegor Zhukov (center) among his jubilant supporters after his release on a suspended sentence on December 6 in Moscow.

MOSCOW -- When Yegor Zhukov exited the Moscow courthouse to a throng of supporters who had waged a months-long campaign for his freedom, he credited them for his unexpected release.

“The fact that I'm here now, and everything that's happening, is thanks to you,” Zhukov said after the December 6 hearing concluded, thrusting a clenched fist into the air. "This is your victory."

The student, YouTube blogger, and self-avowed libertarian has emerged in recent months as the face of a new youth vanguard in the Russian opposition movement.


Prosecutors recommended a harsh prison term for the charge he faced: inciting extremism online. Instead, the judge handed Zhukov a three-year suspended sentence with restrictions on Internet use and access to his popular video blog.

All morning, hundreds of people jammed the sidewalks outside the court in a western district of Moscow, expecting to see the 21-year-old student placed behind bars. Instead, they got the chance to live-stream his surprise victory speech to the whole country.

It was not the first time public pressure appeared to force Russian authorities to backtrack on high-profile criminal cases.

A YouTube Campaign

An articulate political science student at Moscow's prestigious Higher School of Economics, Zhukov had used his YouTube channel to vent against the government of President Vladimir Putin and promote various protest movements across Russia.

He posted his final video on August 1, at the peak of a wave of rallies that swept the Russian capital almost weekly over the summer. He urged his followers not to give up the fight, despite an intensifying clampdown.

Russian Activist Blogger Gets Suspended Sentence After Anti-Putin Videos
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:01:55 0:00


Several hours after the video went online, police raided Zhukov’s apartment in the dead of night and took him into custody.

From the day of his arrest, Zhukov’s supporters staged regular pickets outside the Moscow police headquarters with banners calling for his release.

Hundreds signed an open letter decrying his persecution as “a trial for the entire university” and urging the school leadership to intercede on his behalf.

Each time Zhukov appeared before the judge for procedural hearings, dozens of students attended, communicating through a channel on the Telegram messenger app set up specifically to coordinate support.

The charges against Zhukov stemmed from his participation in a largely peaceful protest on July 27. But prosecutors branded the event an act of mass unrest, ensuring that anyone detained that day faced jail time if convicted.

Weeks later, at a demonstration attended by thousands, Zhukov’s name and face appeared on banners and posters, with slogans declaring him a political prisoner.

The outpouring of support for him and other students caught up in the crackdown initially seemed to bear little fruit. But prosecutors later changed Zhukov’s charge to incitement of extremism online, a move that was seen as a partial concession in the face of the public pressure.

In September, prominent cultural figures gathered at a Moscow venue for a performance aimed at highlighting the plight of Zhukov and other jailed protesters.

The stage from which they spoke was a copy of Zhukov’s bedroom, complete with the 18th-century U.S. flag known as the Gadsden Flag, a libertarian symbol that provided a backdrop for his regular YouTube monologues.

Rapper Oxxxymiron (center) wore a T-shirt in support of Zhukov during a rally in Moscow in August.
Rapper Oxxxymiron (center) wore a T-shirt in support of Zhukov during a rally in Moscow in August.

Among those who rallied to Zhukov’s cause was one of Russia’s most popular rap stars, Oxxxymiron.

"The Moscow Case is truly our common case," Oxxxymiron told the audience, using a popular name for the mass trial of people who took to Moscow’s streets. “How we live in the years to come depends on its outcome.”

'We Thank The People'

That rally took place the same week as 23-year-old actor Pavel Ustinov was sentenced to 3 1/2 years for dislocating the shoulder of a police officer. The verdict came despite video evidence to the contrary.

Ustinov’s arrest had also drawn a large public outcry from prominent Russian figures, including many cultural and artistic figures.

The day that rally was held, authorities unexpectedly reversed their decision and released Ustinov from custody.

”We did not expect such an outcry,” Ustinov’s sister Yulia told journalists upon hearing the news. “We thank the people, the media outlets, the public, and even the prosecutor.”

She was not the first to credit a public outcry for an apparent about-face from authorities.

In June, reporter Ivan Golunov, who gained renown for his deep research in public procurement databases and land registries and investigative reports on the wealth of Moscow city officials, was arrested, charged with possession of illegal drugs.

As with Ustinov, the case struck a chord in Russian society, specifically among Moscow’s liberal-leaning political and cultural classes. Three major newspapers printed identical front pages that read “I/We Are Ivan Golunov.”

About a week later, authorities freed him.

At the time, few concluded that public pressure could be a reliable tool to pressure authorities on criminal cases.

“This kind of success as in the case of Golunov is isolated," Maria Snegovaya, a fellow at the Center for European Policy Analysis, told RFE/RL after Golunov’s release. “They don't accumulate to fundamentally change the system.”

The unexpected verdict in Zhukov case suggests that may be changing.

After Zhukov’s verdict was announced, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov suggested public outcry had played a role.

“We saw various discussions about this and various points of view,” Peskov told reporters. “We don’t turn a blind eye to anything. We carefully follow everything.”

Not A Final Victory

Oxxxymiron was one of many public figures who joined the crowds outside the Moscow courthouse on December 6 in anticipation of Zhukov’s verdict.

After news of Zhukov's release, Oxxxymiron thanked the crowd for not giving up hope, saying that “drawing attention to such things really works.” He urged people to apply the same energy to supporting other defendants.

“There's a mass of other trials taking place,” he said. “We were able to do something here, but unfortunately our resources are limited.”

Political scientist Yekaterina Schulmann, who also attended the courthouse rally, was less optimistic.

“A suspended sentence means a criminal record, and a criminal record seriously limits a person and all his future life choices," she told the TV channel Dozhd. "There's nothing good in that."

Still, even as Zhukov and his supporters celebrated the verdict, other courts in Moscow handed down verdicts against three other activists for similar charges: Nikita Chirtsov, who received one year in prison; Pavel Novikov, who was fined 120,000 rubles ($1,900); and Vladimir Emelyankov, who received a two-year suspended sentence.

The Meshchansky district court also handed Yegor Lesnykh and Maksim Martintsov three and two-and-a-half year prison terms, respectively. Aleksandr Mylnikov was given a two-year suspended sentence. All three had been charged with "attacking a law enforcement officer in a group," during the July 27 Moscow rally.

In total, seven people were handed verdicts by courts in Moscow on December 6 on charges stemming from the wave of protests that erupted in the Russian capital this past summer.

Speaking to his jubilant supporters on December 6, Zhukov did not change his tone, or retreat from his defiance.

"This is not a final victory,” he shouted. “They've turned the court into an institute of repression, and we must fight it.”

Footage Shows Crackdown On Iranian Protests
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:01:24 0:00

The UN's human rights chief has accused Iranian security forces of using “severe violence” against protesters and “shooting to kill” during last month’s demonstrations against a sharp hike in gas prices.

UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Michelle Bachelet said on December 6 that she is alarmed at the continuing lack of transparency about casualties and the treatment of thousands of detainees in the wake of the recent protests.

“Verified video footage indicates severe violence was used against protesters, including armed members of security forces shooting from the roof of a Justice Department building in one city, and from helicopters in another,” Bachelet said.


“We have also received footage which appears to show security forces shooting unarmed demonstrators from behind while they were running away and shooting others directly in the face and vital organs -- in other words shooting to kill.

“These are clear violations of international norms and standards on the use of force, and serious violations of human rights.”

Protests erupted on November 15 after the government announced a fuel price hike of up to 200 percent but were quickly stifled by security forces. A weeklong, near-total Internet blackout was also imposed.

Information has trickled out of Iran during and after the protests, with the U.S. State Department estimating that more than 1,000 people may have died during the unrest.

There has been no widely accepted claim matching that estimate.

Amnesty International said on December 2 that at least 208 people are believed to have been killed during the crackdown.

Iranian authorities have yet to publish any definitive official death toll for the unrest, which saw protesters attack police stations, torch petrol pumps, and loot shops.

Bachelet called for “greater transparency” from Iranian officials with regard to the protests, including giving those detained access to due process and launching “prompt, independent, and impartial investigations into all violations that have taken place, including the killing of protesters and reported deaths and ill-treatment in custody.

“All in all, the picture now emerging from Iran is extremely disturbing,” Bachelet said.

Load more

About This Blog

"Watchdog" is a blog with a singular mission -- to monitor the latest developments concerning human rights, civil society, and press freedom. We'll pay particular attention to reports concerning countries in RFE/RL's broadcast region.

Subscribe

Journalists In Trouble

RFE/RL journalists take risks, face threats, and make sacrifices every day in an effort to gather the news. Our "Journalists In Trouble" page recognizes their courage and conviction, and documents the high price that many have paid simply for doing their jobs. More

XS
SM
MD
LG