Accessibility links

Breaking News

Watchdog

Many Iranians have been angered by the removal of the images of several girls from the cover of a math textbook. Authorities said the cover was “overcrowded" and erased the girls, though three boys still appear on the new edition of the textbook (image on left).
Many Iranians have been angered by the removal of the images of several girls from the cover of a math textbook. Authorities said the cover was “overcrowded" and erased the girls, though three boys still appear on the new edition of the textbook (image on left).

There's outrage among Iranians over the removal of the images of girls from the cover of a third-grade math textbook in what critics say highlights gender discrimination and the sexist attitude of the country's officials.*

The Education Ministry said the original cover showing two girls and three boys playing under a tree was "overcrowded" and that those who reviewed the book from "an artistic, aesthetic, and psychological perspective" had proposed to make it "less crowded." The ministry added that the girls are included inside the textbook as well as on the cover of other math textbooks.

But the decision has infuriated both women and men who have taken to social media to protest what they see as the removal of women and point out that the first and so far only woman to receive the Fields Medal, the equivalent of the Nobel Prize in mathematics, was from Iran.

The late Iranian mathematician Maryam Mirzakhani (file photo)
The late Iranian mathematician Maryam Mirzakhani (file photo)

Stanford University Professor Maryam Mirzakhani received the Fields Medal, the most prestigious international mathematical prize, in 2014.

She died three years later at age 40 after a long battle with cancer that caused an outpouring of grief among Iranians, including the country's leaders, who said her passing had caused "great sorrow."

Many posted Mirzakhani's photos on social media while others photoshopped or glued her photos on the cover of the math textbooks using the hashtag, in Persian, #womencannotbeeliminated.


"An Iranian woman named Maryam Mirzakhani was the century's most prominent figure in mathematics. Now you have erased photos of girls from third-grade math textbooks?" user Mahsa Nasrollahi wrote on Twitter.

Politician Ebrahim Asgharzadeh, one of the leaders of the 1979 U.S. Embassy takeover, said in a post on Instagram that "the policy of elimination [of women] and gender segregation has reached the bottom line."

"My daughter: paste the photo of Mirzakhani on the cover of the book and be proud that you're a girl," Asgharzadeh added.


Iran's vice president for women and family affairs, Masoumeh Ebtekar, posted the cover of the third-grade math textbook next to the all-girl cover of a third-grade science textbook and said the two should be seen together. She added that Education Minister Mohsen Haji Mirzaee had included "gender justice" on his agenda.


Ebtekar admitted that people's "sensitivity" on the issue was appropriate.

"Girls cannot be ignored," she added on Twitter.

To many critics, the erasure of the three little girls from the textbook highlighted more than four decades of state-imposed discrimination against women, including discriminatory laws that give women less rights in areas such as child custody and divorce and force them to cover their hair and body in public.


"Enough injustice has been done to our girls and women, you cannot ignore half of the society with these games," cartoonist Mahdi Ahmadian wrote on Twitter while posting a cartoon in which the two girls removed from the textbook were being dragged away by two men, one of which was carrying a sickle, an apparent reference to the gruesome June murder of a 14-year-old girl by her father that renewed a debate about the need for legal protection for children and women against abuse and violence.

The father, who beheaded his daughter because he disapproved of her boyfriend, had consulted a lawyer before committing the act to make sure he wouldn't face the death penalty.

*STORY UPDATE: The outrage over the girls removed from the cover of the math textbooks prompted an apology from Iranian Education Minister Mohsen Haji Mirzaee on September 13; he promised to resolve the issue.

“There was some [bad judgment] regarding the removal of the images of girls from the third-grade math textbooks; therefore, we apologize for it and we will correct it,” he was quoted as saying in Iranian media.

He added that schoolgirls in Iran have been provided with “good learning opportunities” and that the effects of this are visible, citing an example of many girls competing in math and science Olympiads in Iran.

Belarusians Continue To March Against Lukashenka
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:00:37 0:00

MINSK – Tens of thousands of Belarusians jammed the streets of Minsk and other cities and towns, as opposition protesters pressed their nearly five-week campaign to pressure President Alyaksandr Lukashenka to call new elections.

The Interior Ministry reported more than 400 arrests in the September 13 protests. Among them was RFE/RL photographer Uladz Hrydzin, who was with another photographer in a bar when a group of people wearing balaclavas detained them and confiscated their equipment.

Hrydzin, who was recently stripped of foreign-media accreditation, was detained just before he sent photos of the protest. He is due to appear in court on September 14.

The turnout in the Belarusian capital and elsewhere was the latest indication that opposition activists, and many average Belarusians, have been undaunted by thousands of arrests, beatings, and other intimidation tactics used by Belarusian security forces.

Chanting, "Long live Belarus!" and. "Sasha, you’re fired!", crowds packed one of Minsk’s main boulevards, waving the red-and-white opposition flags and carrying signs that taunted Lukashenka and government officials. One sign carried by protesters showed a photograph of Lukashenka and Russian leader Vladimir Putin and read: "Tell me who your friends are and I will tell you who you are."

Detentions Accompany Another Day Of Protests In Belarus
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:01:46 0:00

Lukashenka, who has ruled the country for 26 years, has refused to hold talks with his opponents, and rebuffed calls to hold new elections. The United Nations has estimated up to 6,000 people have been subjected to detentions and, in some cases, torture by Belarusian security agents.

Lukashenka made no public comment, or any public appearances, on September 13, one day before he was scheduled to fly to Russia to meet Putin for talks.

Authorities did not immediately release any estimate of the crowds; in the past, however, the public figures have been exceedingly low. The human rights group Vyasna, meanwhile, estimated the turnout at more than 150,000.

Tens of thousands of opposition supporters are estimated to have marched through the streets of Minsk on September 13.
Tens of thousands of opposition supporters are estimated to have marched through the streets of Minsk on September 13.

Trucks and some armored vehicles belonging to law enforcement agencies could be seen parked along some central Minsk streets, and, ahead of the demonstration, the Interior Ministry said it had increased police and troop numbers "to prevent illegal action by protesting citizens."

Some activists reported Internet outages in Minsk, a possible repeat of what happened in the hours after the August 9 election. Activists said the outages then were a tactic aimed at shutting down independent news reporting.

Helmeted security forces were reported to be detaining some marchers in parts of Minsk on September 13, and later in the day, masked riot police were seen marching, and carrying, detained protesters into police vans. The Interior Ministry reported that more than 400 people had been detained by nightfall.


The ministry also said "around 250 people" had been detained a day earlier, for offenses like displaying the banned red-and-white flag and banners, "including an insulting one."

Sizable protests also took place on September 13 in the southeastern city of Homel, and in the western border city of Brest, where activists reportedly carried a banner that read, "Hello to Khabarovsk from Brest" -- a reference to the weeks of anti-government protests that have occurred in the Russian Far Eastern city of Khabarovsk.

Brest police deployed a water cannon at one point to disperse protesters. It was unclear if there were detentions or injuries from the confrontation.

"Participants in the unauthorized mass gathering blocked traffic and public transport and created a threat to the safety of road users," Interior Ministry spokeswoman Olga Chemodanova said in a post on Telegram.

A day earlier, hundreds of women marched through Minsk, confronting masked riot police and security agents. The Interior Ministry said 114 people had been detained around the country, 99 of them in the capital, in connection with those demonstrations.

Police Crack Down On Women’s Protest In Minsk
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:01:21 0:00

The Interior Ministry's press department, meanwhile, described the women protesters as "aggressive."

"It's a shame to watch: screams, screeching..." the ministry said. "Such behavior is unfeminine."

Many of Belarus’s most prominent opposition leaders are women, including exiled presidential candidate Svyatlana Tsikhanouskaya and detained members of the Coordination Council like Maryya Kalesnikava and Lilia Vlasova.

Tsikhanouskaya, who fled to Lithuania after the election amid reports she might be arrested, appealed for protesters to "remain peaceful" and urged international support to encourage a peaceful resolution to the "deep political crisis."

Kalesnikava reportedly tore up her passport to avoid being forced out of the country after being snatched off the street in Minsk, and remains in Belarusian detention. Another prominent leader is Veranika Tsapkala, who went to Ukraine and then Poland along with her ex-diplomat husband.

Tsikhanouskaya, Kalesnikava, and Tsapkala have been nominated for this year's Sakharov Prize for human rights activities.

At the Belarusian State University in Minsk, teachers from the languages department issued a video appeal for freedom of speech. More than a dozen students were detained last week at a protest near the school's languages department.

"Fear is bad, violence is bad, lies are bad. You can’t pretend like nothing’s happening," the appeal, which included nine speakers, said.

Lukashenka has long had a sizable base of support, particularly from the country’s older population, many of whom are nostalgic for the Soviet period. But cracks have also opened among segments of the population, like blue-collar workers, where Lukashenka has traditionally sought vocal public support in the past.

The strike committee at one of the world's largest processors and exporters of potash fertilizer, Belaruskali, said via Telegram on September 13 that one of its members had been detained and was at a local police station.

Belarusian President Alyaksandr Lukashenka (left) with his Russian counterpart, Vladimir Putin (file photo)
Belarusian President Alyaksandr Lukashenka (left) with his Russian counterpart, Vladimir Putin (file photo)

Lukashenka, meanwhile, was scheduled to travel to Russia to meet President Vladimir Putin on September 14. Though the two have spoken more than five times by phone since August 9, the meeting, to be held in Black Sea resort of Sochi, will be the first face-to-face talks since Lukashenka publicly pleaded for help from Moscow to put down the demonstrations.

Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said their talks would focus on energy cooperation and bilateral ties.

Putin has pressed a reluctant Lukashenka on closer military and political integration between their countries -- including by promising military assistance under a bilateral military pact, including a police force -- but has largely given only tepid support.

Opposition websites and social-media supporters have adopted the slogan, "We won't let him sell the country" ahead of the Sochi meeting.

Russia's Defense Ministry said on September 13 that its troops would participate alongside Belarusian soldiers in the annual Slavic Brotherhood tactical exercise at a training range in western Belarus.

A Russian paratrooper division will take part in the drills beginning on September 14, it said.

Ales Byalyatski, the director of the Vyasna human rights center, warned that Lukashenka would seek to intensify detentions and threats ahead of the Putin meeting "to show the Kremlin that the protests are abating and he is in control of the situation."

“But so far repression has had the opposite effect,” he said.

With reporting by Current Time, Interfax, and TASS

Load more

About This Blog

"Watchdog" is a blog with a singular mission -- to monitor the latest developments concerning human rights, civil society, and press freedom. We'll pay particular attention to reports concerning countries in RFE/RL's broadcast region.

Subscribe

Journalists In Trouble

RFE/RL journalists take risks, face threats, and make sacrifices every day in an effort to gather the news. Our "Journalists In Trouble" page recognizes their courage and conviction, and documents the high price that many have paid simply for doing their jobs. More

XS
SM
MD
LG