Accessibility links

Breaking News

Watchdog

Vladimir Putin made his remarks at the Valdai Discussion Club in Sochi.
Vladimir Putin made his remarks at the Valdai Discussion Club in Sochi.

President Vladimir Putin has threatened U.S. media operating in Russia, saying Moscow would retaliate if U.S. officials put restrictions on Russian media in the United States.

The comments from Putin came October 19 during an appearance at a meeting of Russian and international foreign policy experts known as the Valdai Discussion Club, held in the Black Sea resort of Sochi.

Officials with Russian state-funded media, including the RT TV channel formerly known as Russia Today and the news website Sputnik, say those organizations' American units have been ordered to register under a decades-old law known as the Foreign Agents Registration Act.

The law was passed in the 1930s aimed at limiting the spread of Nazi propaganda in the United States.

Since a U.S. intelligence report in January accused RT and Sputnik of being part of a Russian campaign to meddle in the 2016 presidential election, a growing chorus of officials in Washington have called on those Russian media to comply with the law.

The Justice Department has not confirmed that it issued any order to RT or Sputnik.

Russian officials, meanwhile, have suggested they could restrict the work of some U.S. media in Russia, including CNN, Voice of America, and RFE/RL.

Putin echoed those remarks in his Valdai comments, though he did not specify what restrictions Moscow would take.

"In this case we will do it only in kind and quite quickly, as soon as we see steps [to pressure] our media, there will immediately be an answer," Putin said.

While RT distributes its programs freely in the United States on cable television, and Sputnik has an FM frequency in Washington, RFE/RL and Voice of America have no access to cable TV in Russia.

RFE/RL once had nearly 100 radio channels inside Russia, but had lost all of them by 2012.

n May, Ruslan Sokolovsky was found guilty of hate speech and insulting religious believers' feelings when he aired profanity-laced clips in which he mocked Christianity and Islam and played Pokemon Go in a church.
n May, Ruslan Sokolovsky was found guilty of hate speech and insulting religious believers' feelings when he aired profanity-laced clips in which he mocked Christianity and Islam and played Pokemon Go in a church.

MOSCOW -- A poet in the southern region of Krasnodar is being investigated in what is thought to be the first criminal case opened by Russian police into allegations of insulting the feelings of atheists.

The investigation into Maksim Drozdov was opened under legislation that criminalizes “insulting believers’ religious feelings” and is typically used to defend the powerful and politically well-connected Russian Orthodox Church and its followers.

Signed into law in 2013, the legislation exemplifies what many regard as a conservative shift toward "traditional" values in President Vladimir Putin’s third term as president, as well as the rising influence of the Orthodox Church. Critics say it has been used to stifle freedom of expression and is open to abuse.

The case against Drozdov was launched over poetry posted on the social network VK on the page of a satirical group called Patriotic Work (Patrioticheskoe Tvorchestvo). The line of verse that attracted authorities' attention read: “There aren’t people worse than dreadful atheists, we will bring back the Inquisition yet!”

In a Facebook post on October 18, Drozdov’s lawyer, Aleksei Avanesyan, quoted from an “analysis” of his client’s poetry included in the police's case file. The document asserted that comments had been identified that “negatively assess” atheists on the basis of their religion. It said those comments “call for hostile activities by one group (believers in God) on another group of people (those who do not believe -- atheists).”

An unnamed Investigative Committee spokesman told the Argumenty I Fakty newspaper on October 19 that “poetry with extremist content was published on a social network in May this year.” The spokesman said the investigation was launched following citizen complaints and is still under way.

In comments to the RBC business holding, however, Drozdov protested that his poems had been misunderstood. Describing his views as "antifascist," he said the poems are satirical works seeking to mock not atheists but the “obscurantism” of religious fanatics in the country.

He said they “mocked obscurantism and predicted the imminent arrival of the Inquisition,” an apparent reference to the rising prominence of radical Orthodox activists in the country. He described the poem as "trolling," written from the perspective of an imagined writer.

He also told RBC that he wasn't the author of the second poem -- that he had received it and corrected some mistakes in it before publishing it on the group page. He said he deleted it soon afterward.

In a VK post, the Patriotic Work group on October 18 also wrote that the poems had been misunderstood. It called them “everyday banter about religious fanatics, about the idiots who today are threatening terror attacks on cinemas,” a reference to radical Orthodox activists who have threatened violence if Matilda, a new film about Tsar Nicholas II’s affair with a ballerina, is screened.

The group noted the irony of Drozdov's situation, saying the poem sought to mock “those who are calling for a return to the 16th century” but that “atheists took it as an insult on them.” It wrote “Hands off Drozdov” and “No to [criminal] articles against thought crimes!”

The Patriotic Work group carries the banner “In Heaven There Is God, On Earth There Is Statesman Vladimir Putin” and carries a picture depicting Putin as a Roman emperor with a halo around his head.

The law on religious feelings was passed in 2013 after women from the Pussy Riot punk collective were jailed for shooting a music video at the altar of Moscow's Christ the Savior Cathedral in which they attacked close ties between the church and the Kremlin.

Since the law was passed, several Russians have been prosecuted and convicted. Although none has received prison time, the cases have attracted international attention.

In May, Ruslan Sokolovsky was found guilty of hate speech and insulting religious believers' feelings when he aired profanity-laced clips in which he mocked Christianity and Islam and played Pokemon Go in a church. He was given a 3 1/2-year suspended sentence.

Other cases have seen Russians prosecuted for lighting a cigarette with a church candle or using a religious icon as a paintbrush.

The law on insulting religious feelings has irked known atheists, including veteran journalist Vladimir Pozner, who in May asked rhetorically on his national Channel One TV show whether publicly voicing his atheist views could land him in jail.

Load more

About This Blog

"Watchdog" is a blog with a singular mission -- to monitor the latest developments concerning human rights, civil society, and press freedom. We'll pay particular attention to reports concerning countries in RFE/RL's broadcast region.

Subscribe

Journalists In Trouble

RFE/RL journalists take risks, face threats, and make sacrifices every day in an effort to gather the news. Our "Journalists In Trouble" page recognizes their courage and conviction, and documents the high price that many have paid simply for doing their jobs. More

XS
SM
MD
LG